Four cotton growing states records 68% of the Farmers Suicides: NCRB 2012 data shows

National Crime Records Bureau Report-2012 shows increasing agrarian crisis in Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra

The latest report of National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) shows that the total farmers suicides recorded during the year 2012 were 2,84,694 in the last eighteen years. NCRB started documenting the ‘Farmers Suicides’ as a separate category under self employed from 1995 onwards.

Four states Andhra Pradesh, Maharashtra, Karnataka and Madhya Pradesh which are predominantly growing cotton in rainfed conditions records 68% of the farmers’ suicides. The two major states Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh have shown increase of 13% and 17% respectively compared over last year and together account for 46% of the total farmers’ suicides.

Weaving a soft cottony story
Published: February 24, 2013 16:12 IST | Updated: February 24, 2013 16:12 IST


Back to the basics: Vijayalakshmi and Mani believe going back to organic is the only way. Photo: BHagya Prakash K.

Mani and Vijayalakshmi tell us the fascinating story of how farmers in Karnataka and weavers in Tamil Nadu together bring out an ethical and sustainable range of weaves that includes all.

If you began this story with ‘Once upon a time…’ it would sound fairly long ago and suitably fairytale-like. But the story of Mani Chinnaswamy and Vijayalakshmi Nachiar is not so distant, though at the end, everybody lived happily. It’s a story that travels between Pollachi in Tamil Nadu and H.D. Kote in Karnataka. It’s a story that travels between farmers here and weavers there. It’s a story that travels from the farm to boutiques.

At a time when the country is opening up to MNC clothing companies , Mani and Vijayalakshmi decided to go back to the fabric synonymous with India — cotton. Mani, a third-generation inheritor of the family’s cotton mill Appachi Cotton, in Pollachi, Tamil Nadu, decided in 2006 that they should be an “ethical” business. “So we quit our conventional business,” say Mani, an MBA graduate from the U.S.A. The couple were recently in Bangalore for an exhibition of their products.

It was a decision driven by a whole chain of thought — cotton farming in India had gone beyond being chemically intensive to genetically modified (GM). A traditionally organic farming culture, with overuse of fertilizers, had failing soil, subsequent crop loss, farmers forcibly moving to GM crop because of low yields, farmers being in debt, leading to suicides… “Over 10 years we lost almost all our native seeds. The solution to reviving the soil, we thought, was going back to organic…it’s the only way. And it’s no rocket science. Most of our farmers have been organic by default. We are only making it a planned event.” And so started their Eco-Logic Project.

They partnered with the Savayava Krishikara Sangha in Karnataka, buying up native seeds that were in cold storage for three years from the Karnataka State Seeds Corporation, Hebbal. But why Karnataka? “Every cotton crop requires a climactic specific condition,” says Vijayalakshmi. “For example, varieties like the Dharwad Cotton Hybrid revived looms from Bengal to Trivandrum. Moreover the weather in Karnataka is best suited for cotton crops. Native seeds are hardy, and the shine and lustre of the cotton is intrinsically built into our picking and weaving traditions. Our interest lies in protecting our own identity,” says Mani. Mani had earlier experimented with the idea of contract farming, providing the farmer assurance that all his cotton crop will be bought, in 2000, with Tibetean farmers settled in Mundgod, in Uttara Kannada district.

The area they worked on reviving organic cotton farming was in H.D. Kote on the banks of the Kabini river in Karnataka. It’s a UNESCO-recognised site as part of the Nilgiris Biosphere where 65,000 acres was under cotton cultivation on the edge of the forest zone. When the Kabini dam was built, farmers were moved out of their agricultural land and had consequently turned to GM crops. “It takes about three years for a farm to get certified as organic,” says Mani. They have about 165 farmers in their network now. They don’t offer farmers a pre-fixed price, but a minimum support price; else, a market committee is formed that fixes the price in keeping with market rates.

Vijayalakshmi, a textile graduate, decided that the cotton they grew and ginned should be made into yardage; but that didn’t work because at that time there was no market for organic cotton; in fact perception in international markets was that Indian cotton was one of the most polluted. “That’s when the idea of value addition came in…weavers too have the same sad story as farmers. The weaver works for a wage, gets no recognition for his work, and so doesn’t want his children to continue in that profession,” she surmises. The couple built a 22-room studio with traditional jacquard looms. They also run a free-education school for the children of weavers.

“We finally felt the whole chain was ethical and included everybody — therefore, our brand ‘ethics’ and ‘us’,” she says. They decided to keep the Indian identity, make saris, but with a different look and feel to suit “occasional wear’ that the sari has become. They roped in designers to work with weavers.

Each of their products carries a tag with a picture of the weaver, his name, how long he took to weave it; they have over 50 weavers working with them now. Organic certified dyes have helped them break the colour palette of beige and brown; its more of jewel tones of reds, pinks, greens and blues.The use of mercerised cotton gives their saris, dupattas, scarves and stoles an almost silk-like lustrous finish.

Not a product, but a story

In 2009, Ethicus was finally launched, and boutiques all over the country were willing to stock their products under the original label. “We were sure we didn’t want to sell a product; we wanted to tell a story,” insists Vijayalakshmi. At the same time, they didn’t want people to buy in guilt, so they didn’t want to harp on the organic bit. Point out the high price of organic clothing, and Mani says, “Look at this way…you, as a customer, are paying a ‘conservation contribution’. We pay 10 per cent over what conventional cotton farmers get for their produce.” All the cotton can’t go into handlooms; so they started making machine-made linens, and knit baby garments, exported to Italy and Australia. Designers are invited to come and use the loom and work with them.

The farmer does multi-cropping and so has food for his family; they are now in a position to sell organic jaggery and ragi…a new area of organic food they are exploring. Of course there were many sceptics asking if such a rosy story was true…their clients were invited over to see for themselves everything from farm to weave. The couple saw another business opportunity and started the Eco Logic Tours!

To know more of their endeavour, check,

Cotton seed production and Child Labor: Various reports

Report on Gujarat Visit Oct 2011



Child labour and MNCs in cotton seed production


Danger Fields



child labor in hybrid cotton seed production in AP 2004

Dirty-Cotton-Report Final

Several reports on using child labor in hybrid cotton seed production.  National Child Rights Protection Commission has taken note of it and ordered an enquiry.  the report submitted by them identifies the problem and suggests remedial measures.  But no major improvement in the situation

Govt likely to withdraw cotton tax

, TNN | Apr 4, 2012, 12.46AM IST

NAGPUR: The market was abuzz on Tuesday with speculation that the 5% purchase tax imposed on cotton in the recent state budget announcements was withdrawn. However, there was no official confirmation. But sources in the government indicated that there was growing pressure from legislators and ministers from Vidarbha and Marathwada for removal of the tax. The tax indirectly hit the cultivators as traders passed on the burden to cotton growers.

There are indications that the matter may come up at the cabinet meeting on Wednesday and the government may give some relief by at least bringing the cotton purchase tax at par with other states at 2%. There were reports suggesting that the traders may not be levied the tax for transactions within the state but may have to pay if they want to take the cotton outside the state.

Social justice minister Shivajirao Moghe, who is from cotton belt of Yavatmal, told TOI that he had taken up cotton tax matter with chief minister Prithviraj Chavan who has sought some more time for a decision for sorting it out with the finance ministry.

Vidarbha Jan Andolan Samiti president Kishore Tiwari has criticized the Centre for curbs imposed on cotton exports and said the delaying tactics was only to favour the textile industry which wanted cheaper raw material domestically delinking cotton from global market. Cotton Federation chairman N P Hirani said in view of the poor arrivals of cotton crop in domestic market because of less than expected crop, the Union government may allow only 10 to 12 lakh bales of fresh exports. “The textile and garment sectors are under tremendous pressure from international competition and the government may find it hard to ignore their interests by freeing cotton exports,” he said.

Last Saturday, cotton traders and exporters, had resorted to an agitation at Pandharkawda in Yavatmal against the tax. Seeking its withdrawal, cotton growers as well traders also demanded removal of all restrictions on cotton exports. Currently the Union commerce ministry is only allowing external trade by the land route to neighbouring countries. It is learnt a meeting of group of union ministers to to review cotton exports on Tuesday was deferred.

Let farmers decide the price’: Mani Chinnaswamy, Apache Cotton

Author(s): Jyotika Sood
Issue: Jan 15, 2012
Mani Chinnaswamy’s contract farming model has prompted IIM graduates to study his Appachi formula. After all, it gives farmers the right to bargain the price of their produce with the buyer. Talking to Jyotika Sood, the entrepreneur shares the hurdles in the implementation of the formula and its potential to change farmers’ lives


Mani ChinnaswamyMani ChinnaswamyWhat makes your formula a novel contract farming model?

Appachi formula differs from conventional contract farming models, especially on the price front. We do not create uncertainty by fixing the price of the produce in advance. Our contract allows farmers to sell their commodity at the prevailing market rate. Though we have the first right to negotiate, farmers are free to auction off the produce in case of a disagreement. We motivate them to form self-help groups to enhance their bargaining power.

Our pricing mechanism usually does not disappoint them as it takes into account the labour put in by the farmer and his family. My company, Appachi Cotton, deals only in cotton because it is a family business, but alongside we encourage our farmers to grow millets, legumes and vegetables, which helps them meet their daily needs and expenses.

Another component of the formula is to ensure that farmers never go short of money and material throughout the cultivation period. The contract assures them easy availability of credit from banks, quality seeds, doorstep delivery of unadulterated fertilisers and pesticides at discounted rates, expert advice and field supervision.

We hear you have stopped facilitating farm credits.

I developed the formula with a vision that everyone who is part of the contract will fulfil their responsibilities. If a farmer takes a loan, he must repay it. It worked well for 10 years. But in 2006, during the assembly elections in Tamil Nadu, some political parties promised waiving off agricultural loans in their manifesto. This led to wilful default by farmers and a bitter end to the idea. To fill the void we started looking for ways to reduce cultivation cost. This made us switch from conventional to organic cotton in 2009. Farmers are always under fear and defensive, applying fertilisers and pesticides indiscriminately, thus increasing cultivation cost. They would sanitise the entire field at the sight of a single insect. There was a need to teach them when to pick up their pesticide guns.

Is organic cotton more profitable than the conventional cotton?

In agriculture, profit can be increased either by increasing the yield or by reducing the cultivation cost. Chemicals and technologies like Bt are pushing up the yield, but they are also increasing the cost of cultivation.

Farmers are organic by default. Through Appachi, we remove middlemen, passing the benefits directly to farmers. An increasing number of farmers are switching from conventional to organic cotton lately. Since the yield reduces during the conversion period, we offer them financial support to keep up their interest in organic cotton. We help them get organic certification.

What are the challenges before organic cotton?

No doubt Bt cotton poses the threat of contamination to organic cotton, but the biggest challenge is seed. All our seed banks have run out of traditional cotton varieties. Hardly any company or agriculture university is coming forward with seeds suitable for organic farming. The government and universities are promoting Bt crops, while people want safe organic crops.

What are the other endeavours of your company?

We have an integrated model for organic cotton farmers and weavers. At present, we have 165 farmers and 50 weavers. We make products like sarees and dress material under the brand name, Ethicus. We put our craftsperson’s name and picture on every piece he creates and mention the time it took to weave the fabric.

Insecticide usage on cotton in India 1999-2010 (Rs crores)

% Bt Cotton
cotton, Insecticide
Cotton fungicide
Cotton herbicide
Total Insecticides in Agrl.
% share of cotton
Total Pesticides in Agrl.

Cotton MSP, farmers’ suicides likely to dominate Maha session

PTI | 01:12 PM,Dec 11,2011

Nagpur, Dec 11 (PTI) The ongoing demand and agitation by farmers over hike in MSP for cotton and unabated suicides by farmers in Vidarbha region are likely to dominate the proceedings of the Winter Session of the Maharashtra Legislature, beginning in the vice capital here from tomorrow. Though the Congress-led Democratic Front (DF) government, citing the code of conduct in place for the municipal council elections, has not increased the Minimum Support Price (MSP) for cotton but has indicated to provide some relief by announcing financial assistance to the cotton growers from Vidarbha, Khandesh and Marathwada regions per hectare. Shiv Sena launched statewide agitation for better prices to the produce and its executive president Uddhav Thackeray had led the agitation in Vidarbha. Though Congress leaders, a majority of them cotton growers, have also mounted pressure on the ruling alliance but are waiting anxiously to hear from the Government on the floor of the House on the hike in MSP. BJP, along with Shetkari Sanghatana, is also on the warpath over the issue. Uddhav even announced that all Sena floor leaders will boycott the customary Tea party to be hosted by chief minister on the eve of commencement of the session. The issue of unabated suicides by farmers in Vidarbha region is also likely to haunt the government again. Vidarbha Jan Andolan Samiti (VJAS), working for the cause of farmers, led by Kishore Tiwari has sought appointment with UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi and has even met other central leaders to press for the demands including hike in cotton. The VJAS has contended that crop failure and inadequate price to the produce are pushing farmers to take the extreme step.

Sreelatha Menon: Blood cotton, blood silk

Sreelatha Menon / November 27, 2011, 0:43 IST

Greek hero Agamemnon pays for the indulgence of walking on a rich tapestry with a bloody end. For farmers in the country, the aspiration to earn more seems to have become their hubris — whether it is the case of cotton, silk, or even ginger, with the state remaining a mute witness.
They are walking to their deaths on carpets of unsold cotton and silk. Or, cotton and silk that is fetching next to nothing compared with their input costs.

Farmers are killing themselves in Andhra Pradesh, Maharashtra and Karnataka unable to bear losses. The Andhra Pradesh government has reported 96 suicides in October this year alone. In the case of cotton, the reason is poor crop and a crash in global prices. Also, farmers have put most of their land under cotton.

The government had a minimum support price (MSP) of Rs 3,300 a quintal for cotton when the going price last year was Rs 7,000 and the cost of production is about Rs 4,000. The prices are down to Rs 3,800 in Vidarbha to Rs 4,200 in Gujarat, leaving farmers in huge debts and no other alternatives as far as crops are concerned.

Ashok Gulati, the chairman of the Committee on Agricultural Costs and Prices, under the ministry of agriculture, blames lack of irrigation (just five per cent compared to 50 per cent in Gujarat), rather than uneconomical MSP of cotton for Vidarbha’s woes. Maharashtra needs to invest in irrigation to improve yields, he says.

The suicides are not a new development. These happen every year, almost in same numbers. Only the reasons change. Between 1998 and 2010, 2.5 lakh farmers committed suicide, an average of around 16,000 or more a year.

In Andhra Pradesh, nearly 25 per cent of all arable land was put under cotton, about 47 lakh acres as against 25 lakh acres last year. In Vidarbha, which is rain-fed and too dry for a water-consuming crop such as cotton, half the arable land was put under cotton.

There is this one instance of Allam Sattenna, a 35-year-old farmer who committed suicide in October this year in Perkalaguda in the Adilabad district. He had two acres and had leased three more for Rs 6,000 for each acre. He planted cotton on all and got just a quintal worth Rs 3,000. A bag of seeds alone costs Rs 900 and the fertilizer as much. His debts were over Rs 70,000, his wife Vijaya told activists of ASHA, a group of farmers organisations.

The case of silk farmers in Karnataka was different. The government lowered import duty on silk last year (33 per cent to five per cent) flooding the market with Chinese silk. About 97 suicides have been reported by the state government till this month. The figures were over 200 for 2010-11, according to the state records, which are always lower than central figures

In Kerala, ginger farmers were faced with a crash in global prices compared with last year, Rs 500 a quintal now against Rs 3,000 last year. Suicides have followed.

Agricultural activist Vijay Jawandhia says if global prices are low, the government should give export subsidies to farmers in the form of transportation subsidies, allowed under the World Trade Organisation agreements. Besides, MSP should be revised, he says.

When prices crash, the American farmers never commit suicide. They are cushioned by subsidies of $ 4.6 billion, he says. He cites what Kamal Nath said, when he was the commerce minister, that Indian cotton farmers are pitted against the US treasury, not US cotton farmers.

Political parties are making hay. The Bharatiya Janata Party and Shiv Sena are demanding Rs 6,500 for cotton in Maharashtra while their governments in Gujarat and Madhya Pradesh have not offered such a price.

They are the chorus to the Greek tragedy of Indian farmers.

No relief for cotton farmers, PM puts off meeting with Mumbai CM

Chief minister Prithviraj Chavan on Wednesday had to call off hisvisit to Delhi to discuss the problems of cotton growing farmers because prime minister Manmohan Singh cancelled the appointment due to prior commitments.

The cotton growing farmers have sought Rs6,000 per quintal for the crop —a price the state wants to consult with the Centre before making any commitment.

Congress leaders from Vidarbha are up in arms arguing that if the state can bear the additional burden of Rs4,000 crore for increasing the price for sugarcane farmers, it cannot ignore cotton growing farmers.

The top leadership in the Congress is worried as delay in the decision regarding hike in cotton rates would go against them in the civic polls.

The cotton growing belt of Vidarbha, which is perceived as the Congress stronghold, is turning into a political battle turf after BJP and Shiv Sena decided to launch an agitation from November 19 and 21 respectively.

State BJP chief Sudhir Mungantiwar said: “We will not allow winter session to take place in Nagpur (Vidarbha) if cotton farmers are not paid Rs6,000 per quintal.”

MPCC chief Manikrao Thakre, who hails from Yavatmal in Vidarbha, has taken the lead to drive the farmers’ plight through closed door meetings with top leadership of state. He held discussions with the CM drawing attention to the problems of farmers in Vidarbha.

+ –
Related links
Prithviraj Chavan discusses cotton price issue with ministers
Left parties, LJP demand revocation of AFSPA from J&K
PM Manmohan Singh lands in Bali
Corrupt people made Manmohan Singh helpless: Ramdev
Manmohan Singh to visit Russia on December 16


Exciting things to do in Pune this weekend

Video: Ronit Roy arrested in rash driving case

Comments | Post a comment | Share this article | Print | Email

Copyright permission mandatory to republish this article.
For reprint rights click here
Top stories on » Popular content »
Breaking news: Cash-for-votes scam accused walk out of tihar jail
Border talks with China in ‘hardest’ phase: Govt
After 100th ton, Sachin Tendulkar to donate bat to Eden Gardens
Women kabaddi team’s bus catches fire, 2 killed, 14 injured
2G accused seek alteration of charges framed against them
OBC mining case: Court rejects bail pleas of Reddys
Families of 2006 Malegaon blast victims seek justice
Peter Roebuck ruined my life, says sexual harassment victim
Cash-for-votes: Government indeed tried to buy MPs, says BJP
Tamil Nadu police book anti-nuclear plant protesters
Day 3 turns out to be a bad morning for West Indies
India clinch Test series against Windies with innings victory
TV channels stay away from ‘breaking’ Bachchan baby news
At hospital where Aishwarya delivered Baby B, doctors still await October salary!
Peter Roebuck ruined my life, says sexual harassment victim
It�s a girl: Abhishek Bachchan announces on Twitter
Salman Khan version 2.0!
Pa, I�m a Pa too: Abhishek to dad Amitabh Bachchan
Comments | Post a comment

Vidarbha cotton growers` convention tomorrow in Yavatmal

Nagpur, Oct 12 (PTI) The Bhartiya Kisan Sabha (BKS), a left wing farmers union along with farm activists and economists will be meeting at Wani in Yavatmal district tomorrow for the Vidarbha Cotton growers’ convention. The meet will be working out a strategy on future agitation as more than three million dry land cotton farmers have already lost cotton crop over two million hectares, said, Kishore Tiwari of Cotton Farmers’ advocacy group Vidarbha Janandolan Samiti, which is supporting the proposed cotton conclave. Atul Anjaan, National Convener Bhartiya Kisan Sabha (BKS) noted economist Shirinivas Khandewale and Shivdas Utane Maharashtra unit president of BKS and Namdeo Gwande, General secretary of Maharashtra BKS along with Tiwari will participate in the convention. Anil Ghate is the convener of this cotton conclave, Tiwari said. Cotton is the biggest cash crop grown in Vidarbha region and in some parts of Marathwada and Khandesh. The price the crop gets decides the fate of three million families in the state which has the largest area under cotton crop in the country. Meanwhile, amid reports that private traders have started buying cotton in open market from farmers at prices ranging between Rs 4000-4500 per quintal, the Maharashtra Cotton Federation has demanded the government to raise the Minimum Support price to Rs 6000 against the current Rs 3300. PTI JOE